They just got a different tool to use than we do: They kill innocent lives to achieve objectives. That's what they do. And they're good. They get on the TV screens and they get people to ask questions about, well, you know, this, that or the other. I mean, they're able to kind of say to people: Don't come and bother us, because we will kill you. Bush - Joint News Conference with Blair - 28 July '06

Sunday, July 23, 2006

Lebanon: 2 key Americans see 1982 in Lebanon '06

In Beirut and Tel Aviv, the two American ambassadors watched the war unfold: Israel's pilots hammering Lebanon, its tanks smashing across the line, its leaders bent on neutralizing an Arab guerrilla threat to the north.

That was long ago. But Samuel L. Lewis, watching today's war escalate on TV screens, hears echoes from that summer of 1982.

"I suspect what we're going to see is going to look increasingly like what happened in '82," says the retired diplomat, U.S. envoy to Israel in 1977-85.

His counterpart in Lebanon during those trying days, Robert S. Dillon, sees a clear historical parallel in Israel's intent, then and now - "the idea that you can, with force, establish a favorable situation for yourself in Lebanon. I doubt that's true."

Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon did succeed in scattering the Palestine Liberation Organization - its leaders, its rank-and-file, its guns - to distant corners of the Arab world.

But along the way Israel's occupation spawned a new Lebanese enemy, Hezbollah, and it's these Shiite Muslim militants who are being targeted in Israel's current offensive.

"That's how it's been throughout Israel's history," Lewis told The Associated Press. "Things settle down for a while, and then the problem re-emerges in a more threatening form."

Dillon said Lebanon's foreign minister at the time, Elie Salem, seemed to foretell 2006 a generation ago as the Shiites of the Lebanese south, rid of the PLO, asserted their own power.

"Salem told me, 'The Israelis have let the Shia genie out of the bottle and will live to regret it,'" Dillon recalled.

The ambassador personally felt the pain of that emerging power. He was among the wounded when his Beirut embassy was destroyed by a truck bomb in 1983, an attack that killed 63 people, 17 of them Americans, and was blamed on the Iranian-supported Hezbollah.

Not only did a new adversary rise up on Israel's northern border in the 1980s, but eventually Palestinian terrorism arose anew in a bloodier, suicidal form in the Israeli-occupied territories.

Looking back, Dillon said, "I'm sure lots of Israelis don't think the 1982 operation was worth it." Read more